Kiran Chetry on the “South Asia” Question

Just in case you were unaware of it, Kiran Chetry, the CNN anchor, is half-Nepali, and was born in Kathmandu. kiran-chetry.jpg

In an interview in Nepal Monitor recently posted on our News Tab, Kiran is asked, predictably perhaps, a number of questions relating to her background. For me, her most interesting response came following a question about her “South Asian” identity:

Question: And this is about being a “South Asian.” Because you don’t really seem like a South Asian unless somebody does some research on you! There are very few South Asians actually doing major shows on cable television in the US. What does being a “South Asian” mean to you?

Kiran Chetry: I define it in a more narrow term. I feel that being half-Nepalese is my heritage, something I have always grown up being proud of and living with. It’s never been something that I dwell on a lot; I think that it’s just my life, it’s who my family is, it’s who my father is. My cousins, many of them that are my age, are here in the US, either studying or now have jobs here. And that is just a part of our culture. And I have lived straddling both.

Fair enough — much of what she said there should resonate with many SM readers. Even if your family isn’t bi-cultural, growing up in the U.S. forces you to always in some sense “straddle both” cultures. But it’s when Chetry gets to terminology beyond “helf-Nepali” (or as she says, “Nepalese”) that she starts to hedge:

But you are right, when people look at me they don’t necessarily say, “Wow, Kiran must be Asian” or “Kiran must be from Nepal.” But I think that when you get to really know me and you spend any time with my family, you see what an influence it is. Since my father is from Nepal and that is what I grew up around. It’s just me.

And there are not a lot of South Asians, if you want to put it that way, that are represented in the news. However, there are a lot more at CNN, which is interesting. We have our special correspondent Sanjay Gupta, also Betty Nguyen, who is on our air and Alina Cho, one of our American Morning correspondents. All of them are Asian, or South Asian. So I think it is wonderful to be able to see more faces of diversity. And, I am one of them, even though I may not look like I am! I think I understand what being part of the Asian culture is like, not to put everybody into one big generalization. But I definitely understand a perspective because it is part of how I grew up. (link)

She seems a bit uncomfortable with the term “South Asian,” preferring the more narrowly national “Nepali” or the more general term, “Asian.” And while she mentions Dr. Sanjay Gupta, she’s also quick to mention Alina Cho and Betty Nguyen.

While most desis I know do define “South Asian” as a subset of “Asian,” I’ve never met anyone who wanted to deemphasize (or reject) the “South” in favor of a more generalized “Asian” identity — to be defined as just Asian, and not South Asian.

What might be behind Chetry’s terminological discomfort? (Unfortunately, we kind of have to speculate here, since I don’t think Kiran Chetry has done any other interviews where she’s discussed these kinds of identity issues.)

203 thoughts on “Kiran Chetry on the “South Asia” Question

  1. 191 · nala on December 24, 2007 11:41 PM · Direct link · “Quote”(?) except for the non-physically active part(I don’t know too many tennis players from Telugu land.. HA HA..) umm… Sania Mirza?

    If you ask any Muslim from Hyderabad, they will never identify themselves as a “Telegu” or as a “Andra Pradeshi”. They will always say “Hyderabadi”. Also, I met the owners/workers of an Indian restaurant, and everyone there were from Hyderabad. They didn’t speak any Telegu, and they never referred to their place of origins as Andhra Pradesh. This is somewhat analgous to non-Marathi Mumbaikars identifying themselves as a “Mumbaikar” rather than a “Marathi”.

    The Muslims of Hyderabad arrived around the 1700s, and their ancestors came from Afghanistan/NWFP via Northern India. This is why they speak Urdu, but they don’t speak (or make an attempt) Telegu. Heck, you’d probably offend Sania Mirza, Tabu, the Nawab of Hyderabad by referring to them as Andhra Pradeshis.

  2. As a Tamilian, I am offended that you think that there is any strife involved in that pursuit.

    Thanks, for the English lesson–Rahul. But you get the point.

    But as for movies, politics etc.. Its a toss up and all states have the same or similar issues.