Dubai — The Beginning of the End?

For the first time that I know of, Desi (Indian, Pakistani, Bangladeshi, and Sri Lankan) workers in Dubai have gone on strike to protest low wages and working conditions. After years of systematic exploitation, it’s about time.

The boom has been possible due to plentiful investment from oil-rich neighbors and armies of non-unionized south Asian workers whose fear of deportation, until recently, kept them from voicing discontent over low wages.

“The cost of living here has increased so much in the past two years that I cannot survive with my salary,” said Rajesh Kumar, a 24-year-old worker from the south Indian state of Andhra Pradesh who earns $149 a month.

The laborers ignored the threat of deportation and refused to go to work, staging protests at a labor camp in Dubai’s Jebel Ali Industrial Zone and on a construction site in Al Qusais residential neighborhood. They demanded pay increases, improved housing and better transportation services to construction sites. On Saturday, workers threw stones at the riot police and damaged to police cars.

Emirates’ Minister of Labor Ali bin Abdullah al-Kaabi described workers’ behavior as “uncivilized,” saying they were tampering with national security and endangering residents’ safety. (link)

Uncivilized? In my view, what’s uncivilized is when you’re making billions and your workers (nearly 2 million of them) are forced to live in prison-like conditions for $149 a month. When they have limited civil and legal rights, and are forcibly segregated from the native population. And when you have laws on the books that prevent them from organizing in any way that might lead to a better situation for themselves.

The era when South Asian workers were desperate to go abroad to try and make a little money under these circumstances seems to be gradually ending, and many in Dubai are more than ready to walk away, especially with a growing economy at home, and the UAE’s Dirham linked to a falling dollar:

Companies, however, do not want more workers to leave as they struggle to find enough to complete existing projects following an overwhelming response to a government amnesty program to persuade illegal laborers to leave.

In June, the government offered, no questions asked, a free one-way plane tickets to illegal workers hoping to leave. They have since been swamped by 280,000 workers who, fed up with a rising cost of living and low wages, were ready to go home. (link)

280,000 are ready to go home right now (NB: they can only go home if the UAE allows them to do so).

It’s true, even if many of the Desis leave, others might be willing to take their place. But with one large reservoir of dirt cheap labor drying up, it sounds like the oasis of Dubai’s recent economic boom is starting to flicker. It may have always been a mere mirage — albeit one built with real sweat, and in some cases, blood.

53 thoughts on “Dubai — The Beginning of the End?

  1. This is chilling and it happend to someone with money and power relative to the desis there.

  2. A quick response to Cyrus since I’m just about to hop on the train to work.

    Mexicans and Turkish people (who have contributed to the economies of Germanya nd the US) at least have the contributions recognized throuh residency and citizenship processes. This is more than I can say for the racist immigration policies of the Gulf where whether you accept it or not, South Asians – from the engineers to brick layers to the business community, built Dubai up step by step. This is goign to be even more so in the new knowledge economy.

    No I guess Jim Crowe is the wrong term to use – apartheid is more accurate. I haven’t seen the “strange fruit that southern trees bear” in Dubai, but Arabs beating up or raping South Asian employees (even killing an occasional worker/maid) and systematic racism – from the street to the corporate offices – were commonplace, as were the segregated neighbourhoods, shopping malls etc. 4 generations in Dubai and my family still needs visas to enter and leave the country. So yes not Jim Crowe – apartheid is more accurate.

    Less S Asian workers in the next 10 years? I keep hearing these threats – I’ve heeard them for the last 15 years and if history has shown us anything, it’s that Dubai especially (but all of the rest GGC countries as well) can’t do without S Asian expertise and labour.