“Black Men, Asian Women” Article by Rinku Sen

Since I don’t watch these television shows, it’s a bit dicey to comment on the spate of shows featuring romances between black men and asian women, so I’ll let Rinku Sen do it for me: parminder_er.jpg

The sugary romance between the excessively noble characters played by Parminder Nagra and Shafiq Atkins on ER follows the much hotter one between Ming Na Wen and Mekhi Phifer that ended two seasons ago. GreyÂ’s Anatomy features Sandra Oh in an up-and-down relationship with Isaiah Washington.

What accounts for such interest? ItÂ’s as though these couples have been pouring out of medical schools and producers decided to capture the trend.

The representations tread the line between cultural authenticity, sometimes considered stereotype, and colorblindness. The women exhibit some level of conflict with their cultures and are slightly neurotic: Ming Na dreaded telling her immigrant parents that she was having a baby out of wedlock; Nagra quit her job in a bout of rebellion against family expectation to work as a convenience store clerk. The men are dangerous but tender. Phifer grew up without a father and has a temper; Gallant went off to serve in Iraq. I did laugh at the effort to bridge cultures, though, when NagraÂ’s character got married wearing a white sari. White is the Hindu color of mourning.(link)

If it’s on TV, is it a reflection of a real sociological trend, or simply a convenient image of happy multiculturalism from television fantasy-land? Sen’s article gets into some sociological explanations for the phenomenon, none of which are terribly convincing (I don’t think these romances have much to do with “American Empire” or colonialism). But she does argue that it goes beyond “submissive Asian woman”/”sexualized black man” stereotypes:

HamamotoÂ’s theory would suggest that such a preference was grounded in a sexual stereotype of submissive Asian women. I am familiar with our so-called seductress image. My Asian girlfriends and I spent our college years snottily rejecting the few white men who came around as “rice lovers.” While I did experience an American man mentioning the Kama Sutra within five minutes of meeting me recently in New York, my adolescent self-image was much closer to nerd than slut. To see all these Asian women who might also have been high-school nerds paired up with the most sexualized actors in American culture has been, I will admit it, a thrill. However, in real life, Asian women and Black men donÂ’t get to be both equally sexy and smart. “ItÂ’s easier for a Black man to get his foot in the door when heÂ’s with me,” said Aarti, “especially if weÂ’re working.”(link)

Class dynamics may be important in the appeal of Asians to some African Americans. And the “bad boy” image (stereotype) may make people of African descent more attractive to children of immigrants traditionally considered too studious and repressed (spelling bee/ math team champions) to be generally attractive.

Or maybe not: since there are no hard statistics, this could be just another Dubious Trend Story in line with infamous New York Times stories about baby gyms in Manhattan, or Ivy League women who decide to drop out of the rat race to become trophy wives. The next time you see an East or South Asian woman dating a black man … it may simply be that they are two people who happened to meet, and fall in love — irrespective of Parminder Nagra, and sociology be damned.

(Incidentally, for Bollywood fans, guess who played Nagra’s parents in a recent episode? Anupam and Kirron Kher, of course.)

552 thoughts on ““Black Men, Asian Women” Article by Rinku Sen

  1. Its so these asian women can piss off their parents even more…

    “You don’t want me to marry a white guy? Huh? Fine. I’ll take it up a notch”

  2. Remember the Jet Li-Aliyah movie Romeo Must Die? Jet Li was the hero, Aaliyah the heroine, and at the end they just smile at each other and don’t even kiss. Why? If it was any other combination, White/Black hero with Asian/White/Black heroine, their relationship would have been sexual. But Asian man and Black woman just did not go. Weird.

  3. Hate to nitpick, but…

    White is the Hindu color of mourning.

    Not always. Gujarati brides traditionally wear a panetar, a white and red sari, on their weddings and I wore an off-white mundu on my engagement, as my husband’s family is from Kerala.

  4. I did laugh at the effort to bridge cultures, though, when NagraÂ’s character got married wearing a white sari. White is the Hindu color of mourning.

    Hindu brides from Andhra Pradesh wear white wedding saris.

  5. Thanks Pooja — I didn’t know about the Gujarati sari, or Keralan off-white (?). (Would it have been ok to wear a pure white sari?)

    And Pablo, yeah, Jet Li was pretty much asexual in Romeo Must Die — just a martial arts/stunt machine. (But that might have something to do with how Chinese martial arts actors know how to act, not necessarily a studio decision.) Hitch might be a more interesting case study: Eva Mendes was hired to play Will Smith’s love interest because a) black+black was considered not commercially viable, and b) black+white still raises eyebrows. Black+Latina was considered ‘in-between’ and therefore safe.

    Black+Asian would also apparently have been safe: Aishwariya Rai was Will Smith’s first choice for a love interest for that film, but she couldn’t do it.

  6. Gujarati brides traditionally wear a panetar, a white and red sari, on their weddings Hindu brides from Andhra Pradesh wear white wedding saris.

    Parminder Nagra’s character was a Sikh Punjabi — a fact that her character was quite vocal about in the show, at least earlier on — and in “real life” such women wear neither saris* nor white on their wedding day.

    *As far as I know. The brides at Sikh weddings I’ve been to certainly didn’t wear a sari.

  7. Parminder Nagra’s character was a Sikh Punjabi

    True. But the author of the piece was spoke of the “Hindu color of mourning.”

  8. Parminder Nagra’s character was a Sikh Punjabi — a fact that her character was quite vocal about in the show, at least earlier on — and in “real life” such women wear neither saris* nor white on their wedding day.

    Yes, but she’s also a rule-breaker, remember? I know a Goan Catholic who wore a red sari on her wedding day. And, let me tell you, that’s not at all the done thing. She was outfitted like a Hindu bride, and there she stood at the altar of a Catholic church. Most Catholic Goans don’t even wear saris in everyday life.

    So let’s give the producers some creative latitude here.

  9. From my understanding/observation, the mundu is traditionally off-white with gold zari or cream and gold with gold zari. I am not sure if pure white would have been OK. Someone who is actually from that part of India could probably answer this question better, although this looks white, doesn’t it?

    (Don’t mean to steer off-topic. It’s a very interesting post.)

  10. I did laugh at the effort to bridge cultures, though, when NagraÂ’s character got married wearing a white sari. White is the Hindu color of mourning

    my dad’s sister eloped with a goan christian when she was 16 (this was in Kenya in the early 60’s). She wore a white sari to her wedding because (according to her) she was celebrating according to her new husbands traditions, and mourning the lost ties with her own (my grandfather disowned her and though they live next door to each other, did not speak, and did not allow anyone else to speak to her for 8 years).

  11. so to get back to the topic…It is interesting. I knew a lot of desi girls in college who dated afican american guys, and most of afroam frineds always talked about how much they loved indian women. Not to start anything but perhaps it is because a lot indian women are “colored” but whith some white-ish/arayan features. And they have curves as well. I know these are gross generalization and touch on issues as to why black men would beattracted to someone with “white” features and that not all desi girls look the same etc, but just one guy’s obeservations.

  12. Mixed Media Watch has given some great coverage to ER & Grey’s Anatomy wrt the mixed-race relationships on the show. I guess my opinion leans towards feeling that they’re trying to mirror some of the sociological diversity in relationships, as opposed to marking a trend or painting some rainbow-happy picture on TV. The fact that the mixed-race couples are presented “normally” as opposed to some overly melodramatic cultural plot point is refreshing, as opposed to treating mixed-race relationships like something to be ogled at the human zoo.

    I’d read an interview with the creator of Grey’s Anatomy, Shonda Rimes, about a year ago– she is a woman of color and was very articulate about how she wanted a multicultural cast, not another show with all-white doctors. She wanted each individual character’s diversity to come into play with the overall ensemble vibe, and she particularly wanted women of color to be in strong lead roles (Sandra Oh, Chandra Wilson)

    I’m glad to see multicultural/mixed-race coupling on TV, and not in some ridiculous “Jungle Fever” fetishism light.

  13. sorry for the multiples– I thought of something else 🙂

    As for Jet-Li, there have been several commentaries (my favorite being Angry Asian Man) about the asexualization of Asian male leads in movies and TV. It seems that hollywood thinks Asian guys are great for fixing your computer, schticky comedy with Japanese executives getting piss-drunk, or karate-kicking bad guy ass, but when it comes down to romance, they completely neuter the male characters. By way of comparison, female Asian leads get stuck with the over-exotified geisha-seductress or “oh me so horny” stereotypes, rather than being portrayed as complex human beings.

  14. Regarding the Black Men, (South) Asian women combination:

    The following points are based purely on my own personal experience here in the UK. There may be transatlantic differences, or indeed differences depending on one’s own social/professional circles.

    it may simply be that they are two people who happened to meet, and fall in love

    It’s certainly been known to happen. However, in a disproportionate number of cases…..

    And the “bad boy” image (stereotype) may make people of African descent more attractive

    Yep. When I was at college — early to late 90s — black men had become particularly fetishised in mainstream British culture and even more so amongst many South Asian girls here. I don’t know what the situation is amongst the college-going crowd these days — I’m 33 — but some desi women around my age do continue this attitude as a legacy from their younger days.

    They also do it a) as a metaphorical middle-finger aimed at desi guys (for varying reasons, eg. they’ve had bad experiences with Indian/South Asian men), b) towards their parents (even indirectly, if their folks are unaware of the situation), c) as an ego-trip about how “unconventional” they are, as — from their perspective — it creates “outrage” from desi guys and more conservative desi women, along with generating kudos from similarly-minded desi women (or those who would like to get involved in such relationships but do not have the opportunity or ability to do so). As we all know, it’s regarded as very taboo indeed within mainstream desi society everywhere (generally-speaking), so the illicit nature of the activities further adds to the “frisson” of it all.

    If the woman concerned is not in the relationship for the “right” reasons, the black guy concerned is either unaware that he is being “used” either as a trophy boyfriend and/or as an illicit thrill, or for various reasons he simply doesn’t care.

  15. Desitude,

    True. But the author of the piece was spoke of the “Hindu color of mourning.”

    Sikhs also wear white during funerals.

  16. I’m glad to see multicultural/mixed-race coupling on TV, and not in some ridiculous “Jungle Fever” fetishism light.

    Yes, but to make the obvious points:

    1. It’s always an asian woman rather than an asian man
    2. Asian men don’t get to be love interests with anybody – either asian or non-asian women

    The reasons are straight forward. Black men, in America, embody masculinity. Asian women embody femininity. But an Asian man is castrated by the media. Consider Gurinder Chaddha – has she ever shown an Asian male romantic lead in any of her movies?

    That said, in England things are different, and I can name a large number of British movies with Asian men in romantic positions. I just can’t do so for the US and especially not for TV.

  17. However, in real life, Asian women and Black men donÂ’t get to be both equally sexy and smart

    I think she’ll be shocked to find out why the stereotyped couples “DO WORK” as I’ve seen with my own eyes in NYC. The exoticization of “asian women” was always (and still is) offensive to me. And yes the token white man that will walk upto you at a bar is usally hoping he’ll get some brown sugar in the form of Kamasutra from you. However the one thing that I have noticed in these relationships is that the men treat the women significantly better then they would if they weren’t percieved as “demure/good” and perhaps they are. I’m a Indian woman and it’s hard for me to not fall into that “good girl the way my mom raised me” role either when I’m in a relationship and perhaps there are men out there that simply like that. Ofcourse these very women like me have other “bitch factors” to them as well so it’s not all sugary.

    I did laugh at the effort to bridge cultures, though, when NagraÂ’s character got married wearing a white sari. White is the Hindu color of mourning

    The last 3 hindu weddings I went to, the bride wrote white!! It was white with gold and/or silver but yeah it was white. I wish the author had done more research at how common this trend is now. Indian weddings usually require several outfit changes. And one of them ends up being black or white. In my mother’s days my mom said women with black clothes weren’t allowed at weddings now it’s trendy.

  18. I think its a conspiracy by white women – who are pointing out to asian (Indian too) women that black men are hotter than white men. I see whiteman – asianwoman combinations way too many than blackman-asianwoman.

    Oh, once at a club, a bunch of black guys asked me, “why dont Indian girls date black guys”. Before I made up any, they offered their own BS that may be blackmen are portrayed as badguys in Bollywood. I was just thinking, “Black men in Bollywood, really?”

  19. I feel compelled to say something since I am an Indian woman who is married to a Black man. I cannot say that the “bad boy” image had anything to do with the initial attraction. Having dated within other communities including whites and south asian, my initial attraction to him really did not have anything to do particularly with his race but more so with his personality. On the topic of race/ethnicity, the one thing that did initially impress me was his pride in his cultural heritage especially since I was so proud of mine as well. But I can’t say that either of us took an initial interest in the other b/c of any sort of racial preference. Of course our relationship has undergone obstacles from both sides, and we still get that obligatory stare from aunties who you can tell are just praying that their teenage daughter does not see us! But this interracial relationship has been such a beautiful experience, obstacles and all, which has broadened the world view of both of our families.

  20. “Black+Asian would also apparently have been safe: Aishwariya Rai was Will Smith’s first choice for a love interest for that film, but she couldn’t do it. “

    Can’t forget Mississipi Masala too.

    “The reasons are straight forward. Black men, in America, embody masculinity. Asian women embody femininity. But an Asian man is castrated by the media. Consider Gurinder Chaddha – has she ever shown an Asian male romantic lead in any of her movies? “

    Wait, are you talking about British Asian or American Asian? Because, in Britain, Asian = South Asian… In North America, Asian = East Asian..

  21. If itÂ’s on TV, is it a reflection of a real sociological trend, or simply a convenient image of happy multiculturalism from television fantasy-land?

    If “medical” TV shows were concerned with keeping up-to-date with real sociological trends, there would have been a South Asian doctor in a leading role long ago.

  22. If “medical” TV shows were concerned with keeping up-to-date with real sociological trends, there would have been a South Asian doctor in a leading role long ago.

    oh snap!

    ain’t that the truth.

  23. Thank you Rashmi, for bringing a really great personal story to the thread!

    Consider Gurinder Chaddha – has she ever shown an Asian male romantic lead in any of her movies?

    IRL Chadha’s husband, Paul Mayeda Berges, is of mixed descent– japanese and anglo. You could argue that with her movies, Chadha is subtley playing up her support for mixed-race couplings. Likewise, her husband is directing T47MBWITW opposite Dylan McDermott in “Mistress of Spices”. After years of seeing TV and movies that don’t reflect “you”, perhaps they’re taking it into their own hands to bring a swirly infusion to Hollywood. You all know how you reacted the first time you saw a desi character on TV or in a movie, a character that wasn’t a token taxi-wallah or freakin convenience store owner; I’m talking a real multi-faceted character that didn’t act like some “bud-bud-bud” caricature of how desis are perceived. Mixed race relationships have been a taboo for a long time, in mainstream entertainment… I think it’s a relief to see them finally reflecting back, and without the stupid stereotypes or melodrama.

    Jet Li- you’re a badass and I think you’re cute, despite how the media portrays you as a pint-sized asexual buttkicker. But if you read my #14, you’ll see that I already had your back, killah.

  24. hey – to whomever just sent me a message via my blog, my email address should be available through link from this comment. and please do get in touch!

  25. Here was a comment I initially posted on Mixed Media Watch when this article first appeared:

    “If there is such a trend in film & television for pairing a black man with an Asian woman, you do not have to look for historical trends, but instead look to political pressures. While interracial dating is more accepted than say 30 years ago, they do not happen in the same frequency. Of the subgroup that dates interethnically (my preferred term), the most common pairing is an Asian woman with a white man, and a black man with a white woman. Film and TV have never had any qualms with the first pairing, but there is still unease about the second, primarily from black women. By pairing a black guy with an Asian woman, writers and producers can avoid criticisms from the usual quarters. The absence of a white partner makes the charge of a minority accepting “majority” notions of beauty null.

    In those instances of black-Asian dating, it does appear (mostly from first-person experience) that it is usually a black man with an Asian woman. But the number of black men with Asian women is far behind that of white men with Asian women. “

    But I would say that the number of instances of negative portrayals of South Asian men trail that of East Asian men. Occasionaly you will have The English Patient, Jewel in the Crown, even Seinfeld (rememebr, candy heiress Sue Ellen Mischke was set to marry an Indian guy before she found out Elaine already has sex with him).

    But if we were honest, we would admit that we only care when good-looking members of our respective groups date or marry outside the group. Most East Asian guys I know don’t care about Sandra Oh’s character dating a black character, cause she’s fugly. Chris Rick joked, “When I see a good looking black woman with a white guy, it makes me mad. I wanna go up to her and say, ‘Girl, what do I got to do to get with you?’ But if I see an ugly black woman with a white guy, I go up to the white guy and say, “Hey buddy, thanks a lot! Thanks for taking her off our hands.”

  26. An article written a couple of years ago by Pius Kamau, which offered an analysis of Brown-on-Black racism rooted in colonialism, enraged many Indian-Americans. While Brother Kamau may have gone to extremes in blaming the sour relationship on the caste system and semi-justifying Amin’s expulsion of Indians from Uganda, the brother does make some good points. There is a hierarchy in many South Asian parent’s minds – and African-Americans are last on the list of acceptability. Any “sociological” analysis of Back-Brown dating should take this into account.

  27. Well, I almost never post anything here, but this subject is sort of near and dear.

    If itÂ’s on TV, is it a reflection of a real sociological trend, or simply a convenient image of happy multiculturalism from television fantasy-land?

    I think that to an extent, if an new type of interracial couple is on TV, it means the media realize there is a new nitch that needs to be catered to. But in this case, I just think it’s a less offensive way to get more tokens in a cast. Also, a lot of black women hate to see black men cast alongside white female lovers, and another minority is a lot easier to stomach. I think this trend stems more from a desire to be PC and not offend black viewers… not a desire to reflect reality.

    “It’s easier for a Black man to get his foot in the door when he’s with me,” said Aarti, “especially if we’re working.”

    I think a lot of people who interracially date- date stereotypes. Minorities, whether they’re brown, black, or yellow tend to have a preference for their own and then white. Its unfortunate to see minorities fall into the trap of thinking they only have those two choices because its then not an indication of an open mind/heart. So usually I’m very happy when I see minority-minority pairings. But I do think this pairing also suffers from stereotypical views…

    Getting to the point though, I think if a person manages to get away from the stereotypes the above quote can really ring with some truth behind it. When both players in a relationship are minorities, especially in America, theres a greater chance for connection with regard to the minority experience. So I can see how/why the quote above could be said.

    BTW, I am not Desi. My relationship is the opposite of this and there have been many situations where I thanked goodness he wasn’t white and could just ‘get it.’

  28. There is a hierarchy in many South Asian parent’s minds – and African-Americans are last on the list of acceptability. Totally agreed. You can also find an interesting take on racism amongst Indians towards African Americans in “The Karma of Brown Folk,” by Vijay Prashad. He argues that the model minority myth also played a part in pitting South Asian Americans against other minority populations ie. Blacks and Hispanics.

    When both players in a relationship are minorities, especially in America, theres a greater chance for connection with regard to the minority experience. Oneup, this is so true. My husband and I always have said that though we aren’t from the same minority background, we still can identify with the experience of being a minority.

  29. To jump in on the side-issue of Asian men being emmasculated in Hollywood movies, four men come to mind who don’t fall into that category:

    1) Daniel Dae Kim, the hunk on ABC’s Lost.

    2) Chow Yun-Fat

    3) Ken Watanabe (Tom Cruise’s co-star in The Last Samurai)

    4) Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson (though he’s half Samoan & half black)

    The common thread with these guys (to my mind) is that they are fairly tall and have a notable physical presence.

    The problem Hollywood has with Southeast Asian men must, to some extent, be due to the fact that, for the most part, they are not tall (by American standards), and the idea that a (relatively) short and slight man could be a hero is anathema to the movie executives.

    This obsession with height has been touched on often in those surveys we’ve all read about that state how CEO and high-level execs in the US tend to be – on average – 6 feet tall.

  30. My question, and I address this from a non-hypenated, non-US-ian, Asian-Indian point of view, but somehow, I’ve always thought that Indian guys would date Asian girls before Indian girls would date Asian guys. And I say this from a deep analysis of that rich tapestry that is my extended social network; I know of a fair number of Indian-guy-Asian-girl couples, but zero Asian-guy-Indian-girl couples. Chow Yun Fatt, clearly, isn’t popular with desi ladies out here.

    So, strike me curious, but how does it work out there for you guys out there in Amreeka? ‘Coz I think you can make a fair case out of a certain undermining, if you will, of the Asian man; our Asian brothers simply seem to lose out in that shallow, sexual rat race that international dating is (just as South Indians do, arguably, and for very similar reasons; our masculine ideal isn’t as Greco-Roman as it is for other ethnicities).

  31. and the idea that a (relatively) short and slight man could be a hero is anathema to the movie executives.

    Tom Cruise Matt Damon Toby McQuire

    just off the top of my head.

  32. 4) Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson (though he’s half Samoan & half black)

    Desi please. Nobody sees The Rock as Asian, they only ever see him as black.

    2) Chow Yun-Fat 3) Ken Watanabe (Tom Cruise’s co-star in The Last Samurai)

    I don’t watch lost, but how much play do either of these guys get in the movies?

  33. When both players in a relationship are minorities, especially in America, theres a greater chance for connection with regard to the minority experience.

    Perhaps true! I had an ex-boyfriend who was very threatened by any instance where I’d get on my pro-brown soapbox. In fact, any time I’d make mention of the minority experience or how my perspective was maybe different than his, as a woman AND a minority, he called me a racist and said I hated white people.

    I was like “dude, I’m HALF WHITE, what kind of internalized racism BS would it be if I developed a white-hating complex?” needless to say, I dumped him soon after. He didn’t get it, and it seemed he didn’t want to.

  34. here’s astinkbomb to throw on the pile. I have been in relationship with “Vhite-ghurl” for while now and we often get into arguments about racism and sexism. Which is more prevalent? Who is more privileged, me the indian male, or her the white girl? These are boiling complicated maters into borad stripes but hey, whats life without irresponsible depictions of complicated problems?

  35. This article by Sen is really north indian becasue in the south hindus wear white saris at weddings.

  36. A couple of years ago, when I was dating a black woman – I also noticed a generational divide in the responses we would get from black men. The black guys my age would sometimes get all competitive, somehow trying to signal to my GF she was making a mistake in dating me. By contrast, older black men (40 and above) had fewer issues – I was the “nice boy” they hoped their own daughters would bring home, who just happened to be Indian.

  37. Abhi,

    Good point, though I find Cruise and Maguire a little too delicate for my taste, and don’t get their wide appeal.

    In terms of Hollywood mainstream movies, those three are relatively recent developments, after a tradition and long line of taller men: John Wayne, Jimmy Stewart, Rock Hudson, Burt Lancaster, Robert Redford, Paul Newman, Arnold Swarzenegger (hey, we’re talking height, not talent), Brad Pitt, Vince Vaughn.

    And I know that these executive choices and mainstream tastes have a lot more nuance and subtext and history to them, I was just refelcting on the fact that height is, or was, a part of the mix.

  38. I am not sure if the minority-minority pair is about something else altogether atleast as far as television and the movies are concerned. LetÂ’s say in any TV show there are 10 characters – eight of them are white and then there are the two obligatory minorities of differing ethnicities, you know to make sure all constituencies are covered. And when the show turns toward the inevitable romantic pairing off. One minority is paired off with the other. To pair a minority off with a white character would (I suspect in the eyes of the shows producers) be seen as introducing an unintentional “interracial dating angle”. While pairing off one minority with another is “ok” because well they are all “people of color” (A term which for some reason makes me wince. It sounds dated. Like something excessively polite white liberals of the 60’s and 70’s might use.)

    When I started this comment I was sure I could remember many examples of this minority-minority pairing for the sake of convenience. The only one that jumps to my mind is Lark Voorhies being paired off with Screech in Saved By The Bell. I wonder if an equivalently attractive white character would have been paired off with Screech. My whole example goes to pot because Screech happens to be white, (but in some sense he was a minority.) But I am still sticking to my theory. : )

  39. Filmiholic #34, do these actors get to be in interracial sex/love scenes though?

    Frankly, I’m quite looking forward to Kal Penn in one (The Namesake. Of course, not a typical Hollywood movie).

  40. Amardeep,

    Telugu hindu brides do wear white. But it is never all white. The borders are strikingly red. (The ones I have seen.) And I think (not sure) Kannadiga brides have a green border. All white without any color would be seen as a sign of mourning.

  41. As a lebanese friend of mine recently put forth insightfully, ‘For a lot of guys from minority and immigrant groups, sex with a white woman is a lot about conquest, revenge for colonization/oppression’. There’s probably some truth in that in many cases, even though we might not recognize or admit it in ourselves.

  42. In fact, any time I’d make mention of the minority experience or how my perspective was maybe different than his, as a woman AND a minority, he called me a racist and said I hated white people.

    I don’t think that all white people are insensitive to different minority experiences… but I do think that MOST are ill-equipped to thoughtfully discuss such issues without some real effort. And I don’t think there are a whole lot who are willing to step up and learn. And while minority experiences aren’t the same, I think in these M/M relationships both pairs are more willing to learn, since they know what its like to have their perspective marginalized. In my case, my being a regular reader of SM stems exactly from that. I’ll admit that I never really had an interest in Indian issues until I started dating my boyfriend, but now that I am here, I make a sincere effort to know about the types of issues that are relevant to his community. I don’t feel he should have to be a walking encyclopedia of all things desi because I hate when people try to make me the spokesperson of all things black.

    Of course, both parties involved have to be aware of themselves for that sort of relationship to surface.

    Which is more prevalent? Who is more privileged, me the indian male, or her the white girl?

    A white person talking about who is more priviledged with a minority… in America… in 2006…? I see SO many things wrong with that conversation.

    Kidding aside, I think from an economic standpoint she has you beat as far as priviledge goes. But as a black female who actually experiences both racism and sexism, I think she needs to sit down with that arguement. Not that you asked.

  43. “here’s astinkbomb to throw on the pile. I have been in relationship with “Vhite-ghurl” for while now and we often get into arguments about racism and sexism. Which is more prevalent? Who is more privileged, me the indian male, or her the white girl? These are boiling complicated maters into borad stripes but hey, whats life without irresponsible depictions of complicated problems?”

    The “isms” that we talk about usually stem from one group being unable or unwilling to understand and relate to the experiences of another group. Now, the question, are those group experiences “natural” or “man-made” Black people had to sit in the back of the bus because a LAW was passed saying so. That experience is man-made. Theres no credible biological base for such different experience, it’s purely sociological.

    I’d say it’s much much more ambiguous how the collective female experience is generated (lets leave out bullshit regimes like islamic theocracies – those need to be changed), but if we talk about secular democracies, the codified laws sometimes actually work in favor of women (In India, don’t women get free seats in the FRONT of the bus?). But the disenfranchisements women may feel (having to balance career & child-rearing, for example? I’m only speculating here) are much more biological and physiological in nature.

  44. Oneup, I definitely agree that not all white people (or brown, or black or any color) are insensitive to minority experience. He was just a bad apple, and I would be cutting off my own nose if I painted everybody with the same brush.

    Good point, though I find Cruise and Maguire a little too delicate for my taste

    filmiholic, (PS, love your blog!) I wonder, do you find them a bit too delicate because of their height, or is it something in their personality (pretty boys?) that comes off as delicate?

    For example, if you have Tom Cruise, and then you have ANNA– towering over him in a pair of schwanky heels… my money is on ANNA for kicking more ass 🙂