Sooden rescu…err…I mean released

By now most people are aware that 33-year-old Canadian peace activist Harmeet Singh Sooden (who celebrates his birthday today), along with another Canadian and one Brit, got their first taste of freedom in months on Thursday:

NOW he looks like a “Gandhian peace activist.”

The three hostages were freed Thursday from a house west of Baghdad by a joint U.S.-British military operation. The kidnappers were not there.

“Right before the intervention, they (the hostages) were bound and then their captors left their building,” said Peggy Gish, a member of the Chicago-based Christian Peacemakers Teams.

The U.S. military spokesman, Maj. Gen. Rick Lynch, said the 8 a.m. rescue from a “kidnapping cell” was based on information divulged by a man during interrogation only three hours earlier. The man was captured by U.S. forces on Wednesday night. [Link]

<

p>The operation to rescue the three hostages was led by British SAS and MI6 as detailed in an article at Canada.com:

CanWest News Service has learned the raid was prompted after the Special Air Service and MI6 — Britain’s commando unit and its spy agency — opened negotiations with a kidnapping network after studying hostage tapes released to Arab television stations. Eavesdropping teams also tried to intercept cellphone conversations between the kidnappers and Arab television journalists.

The Canadian contingent is believed to have included the elite Joint Task Force 2, who were, according to Stephen Harper, “fully engaged and fully aware of what was going on…” [Link]

Now for the controversy. If you listened to the news yesterday you probably noticed that the language used to describe this event varied greatly. Some news organizations and groups said the hostages were “released.” Others, including military officials, said that they were “freed” or “rescued.” If you’ll reacall, these three are members of Christian Peacemaker Teams who oppose the occupation of Iraq and the presence of military there. It would put them in a tough spot if they had to publicly thank the military for Thursday’s events. Using different set of words and phrases can allow these different groups (e.g. military, CPT, and journalists) to all put their own spin on the actual events. I’d like to know more about the facts.

In Toronto, CPT co-director David Pritchard described the news as “release” rather than a “rescue” throughout the day. He said the news sent CPT workers on “a roller coaster of emotions…” [Link]

<

p> We will have to wait for the first direct interviews with Sooden and colleagues to see how they describe the events leading to the end of their captivity.

<

p>So what did Sooden and his fellow captives do during all those months? Exactly what you hoped they be able to do:

The Canadians struggled to stay in shape during their confinement: Ms. David said Mr. Loney did stretching exercises, while Mr. Sooden did sit-ups and ran up and down a flight of stairs. [Link]

See related post: Canadian peace activists abducted (a BEFORE picture of Sooden is located in this post)

53 thoughts on “Sooden rescu…err…I mean released

  1. Vinod-at-large really rather that they expressed gratitude AND help out with rescuing other / future hostages

    Manish wrote

    Perhaps I wasn’t clear: it’s stupid to not say thank you explicitly in their first public statement

    This is bizarre. James Loney thanked the troops that freed him, and everyone else, in his first newsconference in Canada. This obsession with CPTs ‘not thanking the troops’ reminds me of the right-wing war bloggers eternal demands that ‘Muslims condemn terrorism’ while ignoring all condemnations.

    (There’s been some real vituperation in the Canadian press against the CPTs by pro-war columnists. Some people hate pacifists.)

    I like the CPTs a lot, I met one in Montreal that was going to Yugoslavia during that war. They practice what they preach and put their own lives at risk while doing so. And to be clear, they are not acting as missionaries, and you do not need to be a Christian to join them. I don’t think Sooden is a Christian, just an idealistic former Montrealer.