{"id":1991,"date":"2005-08-08T13:46:22","date_gmt":"2005-08-08T18:46:22","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/sepiamutiny.com?p=1991"},"modified":"2005-08-08T12:46:47","modified_gmt":"2005-08-08T17:46:47","slug":"indian_literatu","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"http:\/\/sepiamutiny.com\/blog\/2005\/08\/08\/indian_literatu\/","title":{"rendered":"Indian Literature Weekend Roundup"},"content":{"rendered":"<p>New stuff:<\/p>\n\n<ul><li>Mukul Kesavan on the rise of Jinnah and the Muslim league<\/li>\n<li>Kamila Shamsie on Tariq Ali&#8217;s <em>A Sultan in Palermo<\/em><\/li>\n<li>Amitava Kumar&#8217;s critique of Salman Rushdie in Tehelka; my disagreements with Kumar<\/li>\n<li>Cranky comments from V.S. Naipaul in the New York Times; my bewilderment<\/li><\/ul>\n\n<p><!--more-->1. Novelist <a href=\"http:\/\/www.chowk.com\/show_article.cgi?aid=00000527&#038;channel=leafyglade%20inn\">Mukul Kesavan<\/a> has an <a href=\"http:\/\/www.telegraphindia.com\/1050807\/asp\/opinion\/story_5083180.asp\">essay on the rise of the Muslim League<\/a> in the 1940s (via <a href=\"http:\/\/indiauncut.blogspot.com\/2005\/08\/rise-of-muslim-league.html\">India Uncut<\/a>). He argues that Muslim politics only really consolidated between 1937 and 1942. Key incidents include the Congress&#8217; decision to participate in elections in 1935, and the changes in the political landscape that occurred with the beginning of World War II.<\/p>\n\n<ol>\n<li><p><a href=\"http:\/\/kitabkhana.blogspot.com\/2005\/08\/islam-quintet.html\">Kitabkhana links<\/a> to <a href=\"http:\/\/books.guardian.co.uk\/reviews\/generalfiction\/0,6121,1538818,00.html\">Kamila Shamsie&#8217;s review<\/a> of Tariq Ali&#8217;s latest novel <em>A Sultan in Palermo<\/em> (the fourth of five in Ali&#8217;s &#8220;Islam Quintet&#8221;), in The Guardian. If you weren&#8217;t aware that Palermo (i.e., in Sicily) had Sultans, you might want to read this review, and perhaps Ali&#8217;s novel as well.<\/p><\/li>\n<li><p>Hurree also <a href=\"http:\/\/kitabkhana.blogspot.com\/2005\/08\/amitava-on-rushdie.html\">links<\/a> to <a href=\"http:\/\/amitavakumar.com\/articles\/rushdie2.html\">Amitava Kumar&#8217;s long critique of Salman Rushdie<\/a> at Tehelka. The article at Tehelka isn&#8217;t accessible to the public, so Kumar has posted the article for us at his personal website. Kumar isn&#8217;t just dismissing one of Rushdie&#8217;s books, or even a group of them &#8212; he&#8217;s going after Rushdie as a whole.<\/p><\/li>\n<\/ol>\n\n<p>Though I generally admire Amitava Kumar, here I have to disagree with him, especially the central thesis of this essay &#8212; the idea that what Rushdie has been writing about all along is himself (&#8220;It is impossible to escape the suspicion that the one who is to be redeemed most often seems to be the writer himself&#8221;). There is undoubtedly narcissism there, but there is also a real feel for the subject matter (especially in the earlier books). Not to mention brilliant wordplay, compelling storytelling, and verve. And Rushdie&#8217;s narcissism, especially since it is checked by self-consciousness about the same, need not be a mortal sin. In the right hands, it can also be revelatory.<\/p>\n\n<p>(Incidentally, isn&#8217;t it a little bit odd that Kumar marks Rushdie&#8217;s narcissism in a review that is largely structured as a personal essay?)<\/p>\n\n<p>And this passage in the Kumar essay troubles me:<\/p>\n\n<blockquote>His is no doubt a powerful voice; often, it has been an oppositional voice; but it is a voice of a celebrity promoting commendable causes; more seriously, in some fundamental way, it is the voice of a metaphorical outsider, and therefore incapable of revealing to ourselves, in an intimate way, our complicities, our contradictions, and our own inescapable horror. I don&#8217;t deny that it is a voice that can engage and delight and of course annoy, and yet it is very important to make a distinction: what Rushdie writes can easily provoke, but it is rarely able to disturb. <\/blockquote>\n\n<p>It sounds impressive, but aren&#8217;t the distinctions Kumar is making here a little vague? What is a &#8220;metaphorical outsider&#8221;? To what is Kumar referring to by &#8220;our own inescapable horror&#8221;?  And what is the distinction between &#8220;provoke&#8221; and &#8220;disturb&#8221; in the last sentence? To me, this is a critical sleight of hand: Kumar is telling us that there&#8217;s something not-quite-right about Rushdie (which might be true), but he&#8217;s not really showing us what it is.<\/p>\n\n<p>Finally, it&#8217;s strange to me that Kumar praises the recent Naipaul (<em>Magic Seeds<\/em>) while digging into Rushdie. Kumar has mentioned his own debt to Naipaul&#8217;s prose style before, in <em>Bombay, London, New York<\/em> (which I reviewed informally <a href=\"http:\/\/www.lehigh.edu\/~amsp\/2004\/05\/reading-diaspora-amitava-kumar-and.html\">here<\/a>), and I can fully see how important Naipaul&#8217;s dispassionate, methodical eye might have been to someone like Kumar.<\/p>\n\n<p>The truth is, <strong>both Rushdie and Naipaul do have significant fallibilities<\/strong>. Naipaul has an ugly, sneering side, scarcely controlled in early books like <em>India: An Area of Darkenss<\/em>, or the early African narratives he wrote. He also has a hatred for things Islamic that he has expressed and expressed and expressed &#8212; writing three long, mean-spirited books about the Islamic world, and giving his blessing, before last year&#8217;s elections, to the ideology of India&#8217;s Hindu right.<\/p>\n\n<p>Rushdie is still in my good graces, though he&#8217;s slipping. He may have many of the weaknesses Kumar cites &#8212; chief among them narcissism and a tendency to the academic &#8212; but all in all his voice has done a lot more good for Indian literature than bad. That said, I have no trouble at all accepting Kumar&#8217;s dismissive verdict on the forthcoming <em>Shalimar the Clown<\/em>. With each bad book, people remember the brilliant, compelling, original Rushdie a little less, and think of the smug, &#8220;celebrity&#8221; Rushdie a little more. That&#8217;s a substantial loss.<\/p>\n\n<p><strong>4. Speaking of Naipaul<\/strong>, I&#8217;m surprised that no one has been discussing the long essay on <a href=\"http:\/\/www.nytimes.com\/2005\/08\/07\/books\/review\/07DONADIO.html?ex=1281153600&#038;en=84ff20dd9e7c3454&#038;ei=5090&#038;partner=rssuserland&#038;emc=rss\">him in the New York Times<\/a>, the product of an interview conducted by Rachel Donadio. Naipaul here reproduces many of the comments about the state of contemporary literature that he&#8217;s made elsewhere, though he now seems to be reaching a new, completely unprecedented level of transcendent crankiness. The zinger I can&#8217;t believe he gets away with is his straight-faced claim that the novel is dead:<\/p>\n\n<blockquote>Yet the fact that Naipaul has continued to write novels does not undercut his acute awareness of the form&#8217;s limitations; indeed, it amplifies it. His is the lament of a writer who, through a life devoted to his craft, has discovered that the tools at his disposal are no longer adequate. &#8220;If you write a novel alone you sit and you weave a little narrative. And it&#8217;s O.K., but it&#8217;s of no account,&#8221; Naipaul said. &#8220;If you&#8217;re a romantic writer, you write novels about men and women falling in love, etc., give a little narrative here and there. But again, it&#8217;s of no account.&#8221;<\/blockquote>\n\n<p>This is just one of many things in the interview that one can&#8217;t take seriously. (Another is Naipaul&#8217;s claim that he&#8217;s a better travel writer than Joseph Conrad.)<\/p>\n\n<p>Another bizarre moment is this paragraph:<\/p>\n\n<blockquote>In conversation, another dynamic becomes apparent, in which the more dismissive Naipaul is of a writer, the more likely it is that he has engaged deeply with that writer&#8217;s work. Sitting a few feet away from a bookshelf of French novels, Naipaul called Proust &#8220;tedious,&#8221; &#8220;repetitive,&#8221; &#8220;self-indulgent,&#8221; concerned only with a character&#8217;s social status. &#8220;What is missing in Proust is this idea of a moral center,&#8221; he said. Naipaul also had little respect for Joyce&#8217;s &#8220;Ulysses&#8221; &#8212; &#8220;the Irish book,&#8221; he sniffily called it &#8212; and other works &#8220;that have to lean on borrowed stories.&#8221; Lately, he has found Stendhal &#8220;repetitive, tedious, infuriating,&#8221; while &#8220;the greatest disappointment was Flaubert.&#8221;<\/blockquote>\n\n<p>Here, it seems as if Donadio knows that what Naipaul is saying is incoherent and absurd. But she poses it completely seriously &#8212; as if it makes perfect sense. With the first sentence of the above paragraph, Donadio gives Naipaul&#8217;s literary nihilism a free pass.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>New stuff: Mukul Kesavan on the rise of Jinnah and the Muslim league Kamila Shamsie on Tariq Ali&#8217;s A Sultan in Palermo Amitava Kumar&#8217;s critique of Salman Rushdie in Tehelka; my disagreements with Kumar Cranky comments from V.S. Naipaul in &hellip; <a href=\"http:\/\/sepiamutiny.com\/blog\/2005\/08\/08\/indian_literatu\/\">Continue reading <span class=\"meta-nav\">&rarr;<\/span><\/a><\/p>","protected":false},"author":11,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":[],"categories":[8],"tags":[],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"http:\/\/sepiamutiny.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/1991"}],"collection":[{"href":"http:\/\/sepiamutiny.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"http:\/\/sepiamutiny.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/sepiamutiny.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/11"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/sepiamutiny.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=1991"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"http:\/\/sepiamutiny.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/1991\/revisions"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"http:\/\/sepiamutiny.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=1991"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/sepiamutiny.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=1991"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/sepiamutiny.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=1991"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}