Tuesday is primary day in the state of Pennsylvania. My cousin Manan Trivedi is vying for the Democratic party’s nomination against Doug Pike. The winner will face the Republican incumbent in a district that has a real chance of switching hands in November and will therefore be the focus of national attention. For obvious reasons I have been following this battle pretty closely and here are three observations:
1) Money rules, and being independently wealthy rules more. It doesn’t matter if you rack up double or triple the endorsements of your opponent. It might not even matter if you out-fundraise them. If he/she can afford to put their face up on TV more often than you then its an uphill battle until the end.
And the fundraising is going well for Trivedi. Because of the impending primary, the candidates had to filed with the FEC yesterday for their sums raised from April 1 through April 28. Here’s your totals:
Trivedi: $41,478.50
Pike: $9,381.00
In the month before the election, less than $10,000 raised? That’s Martha Coakley-level complacency not only compared to Trivedi but to other regional Dems who face no primary challenges — Bryan Lentz, in neighboring PA-07, also raised over $40,000 in April, for instance. [Kos]
2) You can enter a race “late,” “come from out of nowhere,” and have a South Asian name and still compete if you have good ideas and know how to communicate them. I believe this is the single most important thing I have learned from this race. I am not sure who will win tomorrow but it was amazing to see that sound policy knowledge resulted in such a lopsided endorsement tally and such a toss-up on election day.
Going into the final full week of campaigning during the primary election season, Manan Trivedi has received the endorsement from two very influential women and an organization devoted to advocating for women’s equality.
The National Organization for Women (NOW/PAC) chair, Terry O’Neill stated that “Manan Trivedi has demonstrated to us that he will stand up for the full equality of girls and women. We are looking forward to joining forces with him in that pursuit.” [Link]
3) Anything can happen in a primary (see Bob Bennett). Primaries are ruled by the most hard-core activists in the party. The people that vote are the ones that probably vote in every election or the ones that feel passionately about a particular candidate or their policies. There aren’t any real polls that have attempted to predict the outcome of this race but we know with absolute certainty that it will come down to anywhere from a couple thousand to a couple hundred votes (more likely the latter). If you live in PA-6th and were debating whether or not to vote then I’d tell you that a primary vote is where your voice will be heard the loudest.
If you live in the PA-6th and vote, please tell us about your voting experience in the comments below.
I’m probably misreading, but–you can buy a seat in the Parliament/Congress of the world superpower for US$ 45,000? Something must be off here, or else I’m going to be in charge real soon! Can somebody fill me in on the reality?
i’m never reading this weblog again because i am offended by shilling for one’s blood relatives. this is a public space and you shouldn’t use it for blah, blah, blah, blah, righteous, blah, blah, blah. there.
You should totally get him to Google bomb he PA 6 district with all Vote Trivedi ads.
What is it with Indians and dynasty? The Indian media conspiring to get Indians elected? This is getting ridiculous.
“this is a public space”
Uh no, it’s a private blog.
@BombayBankerBoy: Definitely takes more money to compete in an election (though I wouldn’t say “buy” necessarily; debatable). The primary elections – happening within the party, prior to the general election – have a lot less turnout and tend of focus around the hard-core and most excitable activists. A little less money in a sleeper race can do it for you at the primary level, while getting a win in the general is another thing entirely.
@Keshav: what is this i don’t even
Uh no, it’s a private blog.
you’re trying to silence and marginalize my Voice. you can not fight oppression and tear down the master’s house with the master’s tool. discourse must be entered into with sincerity and a conscious realization of the multi-textured power dynamics and hegemonic narratives.
How did you manage to control ROTFLYAO as you typed that?
Razib: I bet your sense of Humor will go over the head of most SM readers (except may be few – say like Mustafa;-).